Walmart reported its third quarter this morning, and the most important number for anyone who sells through a store sat two lines below the headline. Walmart U.S. advertising grew 37%, including a 36% jump at Walmart Connect if you strip out VIZIO and Vibe, the TV maker and the streaming ad platform it bought. Walmart U.S. comparable sales grew 2.9%. That is from the company’s earnings release and its results presentation, both dated November 19.
Yesterday it was Target. Its advertising revenue line came in at $296 million for the quarter, up from $241 million a year ago, while comparable sales rose 5.6%. Three weeks ago it was Instacart, where advertising and other revenue rose 23% while transaction revenue, the money it makes moving groceries, rose 14%.
Put those side by side and a pattern stops looking like a coincidence. At every big retail network that has reported this autumn, the ad bill is growing several times faster than the sales it is supposed to produce. When that happens year after year, a growing slice of what brands call retail media is not buying growth anymore. It is the price of staying on the shelf. The sooner your plan treats it that way, the better your 2027 budget conversations go, and most of those conversations start in the next few weeks.
Three quarters, one shape
Start with Walmart, because it is the biggest gap. Walmart U.S. net sales grew 3.6% to $125 billion. E-commerce grew 23%, and the presentation credits that growth to store-fulfilled delivery, advertising at 37% and marketplace sales at 49%. Globally, advertising grew 25%, held back by the timing of Flipkart’s Big Billion Days sale in India, which landed in a different quarter this year.
Target’s numbers come straight from its third quarter release on November 18. Advertising revenue of $296 million against $241 million is growth of about 23%, a calculation PPC Land also made. Comparable sales rose 5.6% on a 5% rise in transactions, a real recovery after a weak year. Even so, the ad line outran the store by roughly four to one. Target says its non-merchandise sales grew nearly 20%, led by Roundel ad revenue, card profit sharing, membership and its marketplace.
Instacart is the cleanest example because it publishes the ratio itself. In its third quarter results on October 29, advertising and other revenue reached $331 million, equal to 3.1% of the value of everything sold on the platform. PPC Land worked back from the growth rates and puts that share at about 2.9% a year earlier. By its count, ad revenue per order rose about 12%, from roughly $3.23 to $3.62, while orders grew 10%. Every basket carries a little more ad money than it did last year.
Amazon is the outlier this quarter, and for a boring reason. Its advertising revenue was $19.6 billion, up 11% as reported and 12% excluding currency moves, a sharp slowdown from 26% in the second quarter. Marketing Dive notes Amazon blamed timing, mainly Prime Day moving from July to June, and guided to high teens growth for the holiday quarter. Read Amazon’s number as a calendar effect, not a sign that the pattern has broken.
Now set all of that against what shoppers are actually spending. Adobe’s holiday forecast expects U.S. online sales of $275.1 billion from November 1 to December 31, up 6.7%. Shoppers are growing their spending in the mid single digits. The retailers’ ad businesses are growing at three to six times that rate. The difference has to come from somewhere, and it comes from brands paying more per unit sold.

Read the footnotes
Here is the detail most media plans never look at. Walmart’s release says its advertising business “is recorded in either net sales or as a reduction to cost of sales, depending on the nature of the advertising arrangement.” Target’s footnote says Roundel services are classified as net sales “or as a reduction of Cost of Sales or Selling, General, and Administrative (SG&A) Expenses.”
In plain English, some of what you pay these retailers for ads does not show up in their books as ad revenue at all. It shows up as a lower cost of the goods the retailer sells. That is the same part of the books where supplier discounts and allowances, the trade money your sales team negotiates, usually land. PPC Land points out that this also means Target’s $296 million understates the real size of Roundel, and Target does not say by how much.
None of this is hidden or improper. It is ordinary accounting, printed in the release for anyone to read. But it tells you how the retailer thinks about your spend. When your ad budget and your trade terms land in the same part of the retailer’s books, the retailer does not see them as two separate decisions. Your media team and your sales team probably do. That gap is where brands lose money.
Why the retailer loves this
Walmart’s gross profit rate in the U.S. rose by half a point, and the presentation says that reflects “improved business mix primarily from growth of digital advertising.” Ads cost a retailer very little to deliver. It already owns the shoppers, the pages and the purchase data. Every extra dollar a brand puts into sponsored listings is close to pure margin for the retailer in a way that a dollar of groceries never will be.
That is good business, and it is also leverage you can use. Your ad money is some of the most profitable money these companies earn. When a network rep tells you budget is tight this year and the good placements are going fast, remember who needs whom. Ad growth carried a real part of this quarter’s profit story at Walmart, and its executives will be asked about that number every quarter from now on.

Rent versus growth
The useful move is to stop treating each network’s budget as one number. Split it into two.
Call the first part shelf rent. This is the spend you need just to hold your position: defending your own brand name in the retailer’s search results, keeping your products from sliding below a competitor’s sponsored listing, meeting the ad commitment that came attached to your annual business plan with the buyer. If you cut it, you lose share you already had. It does not create new customers. It protects the ones you have.
Call the second part growth media. This is spend that has to bring you shoppers who would not have bought anyway: new-to-brand buyers, new categories, offsite and streaming campaigns that use the retailer’s data to reach people outside the store.
These two parts deserve completely different scorecards. Rent should be judged like a trade cost, as a share of what you sell at that retailer, and negotiated by the people who negotiate your listing and pricing, with the media team in the room. Growth should be judged on whether it actually moved sales that would not have happened, with holdout tests or new-to-brand reporting, and it should be the first money you move when a network cannot prove it.
Buyers are already drifting this way. IAB Europe’s Attitudes to Retail Media report, published November 3 from 150 buy side and sell side respondents, found that only 49% of European buyers picked return on ad spend as a measure they want, down from 89% a year earlier. Unified online and offline reporting (66%), new-to-brand measurement (63%) and incrementality (57%) now rank higher. And 61% of buyers say weak measurement and reporting is holding back more investment. Return on ad spend is fine for rent, because rent is mostly about protecting sales that were coming anyway. It is useless for deciding whether growth money worked.
The November trap
The timing makes all of this harder. The next two weeks will produce the best looking retail media dashboards of the year. Black Friday and Cyber Monday shoppers arrive ready to buy, conversion rates spike, and every sponsored listing near a deal looks like a genius move.
That is exactly when many brands lock in next year’s commitments. A buyer meeting in early December, armed with a holiday report showing a big return on ad spend, is how rent quietly gets booked as growth for another year. Most of what you see in Cyber Week return on ad spend is demand that was already there, captured by whoever paid for the top slot. Paying for that slot can still be worth it. Just call it what it is when you budget for it.
Fewer networks, firmer deals
There is one more force pushing the bill up. Brands are narrowing the list of networks they buy. The id8 retail November radar cites analysis by Walrus Intelligence, published in WARC’s Future of Commerce Media 2026 report, finding 73.9% of UK brands spend with three or fewer retail media networks. Mars United’s Europe report card, published November 17, says the question for brands has shifted “from access to allocation.”
Concentration cuts both ways. The biggest networks can raise rent because nobody can afford to leave them. The smaller and mid-sized ones are desperate to stay on your shortlist, which is exactly when they will agree to proper measurement, test budgets with holdouts and terms that separate media from trade. If you are going to demand a better deal anywhere, start where you are wanted most.
What to do this week
None of this needs a new tool or a new agency. It needs one spreadsheet and two meetings.
First, build your own take rate. For each retailer, put four quarters of ad spend next to four quarters of your sales through that retailer. Divide one by the other. If your ad spend as a share of sales went up while your sales grew slowly, you are paying rising rent, whatever the dashboard calls it. Do it before the holiday numbers arrive and cloud the picture.
Second, label every line. Go through each network’s plan for next year and mark each budget line as rent or growth. Be honest. Branded search defense on the retailer’s own site is rent. A commitment the buyer asked for as part of your annual plan is rent. Anything left over has to earn the growth label with a test.
Third, put sales and media in one room. Whoever negotiates your trade terms and whoever runs your retail media should see one combined number per retailer before the next buyer meeting. Ask the network directly whether your ad commitment affects your listing, placement or terms. Get the answer in writing.
Fourth, keep November out of the forecast. Agree internally now that Black Friday and Cyber Week return on ad spend will not be used to set 2027 ad commitments. Use a normal month instead, or the whole year.
Fifth, make growth money conditional. Pick one network, ideally a mid-sized one that wants you, and make next year’s growth budget depend on a holdout test or new-to-brand reporting in the first quarter. If it cannot run one, that money goes somewhere that can.
Retail media still works. The shoppers are real, the data is real, and some of the spend is worth every cent. But the numbers from this week say the ad bill is growing far faster than the shelf it sits on. Pay the rent when you have to. Just stop calling it growth.




