Picture a product page you will see a hundred times in the next two weeks. A jacket, a strike-through price of €249 labeled RRP, a sale price of €149 and a fat “40% off” badge. A little flame icon that says “Only 3 left” and follows you into the basket and then into checkout. A countdown clock with no date on it. A €4.95 delivery fee that appears on the last screen. Somewhere upstream, a creator unboxed the jacket from a holiday gift box with no label on the video, because the brand never paid them, it just sent the box.
Every one of those things is normal. Under the proposal the European Commission published on November 11, most of them would be blacklisted.
The Digital Fairness Act is the EU’s attempt to rewrite consumer protection for how people actually shop now. It would replace the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, which has governed this stuff since 2005, with a regulation that applies directly in every member state instead of being written into 27 national laws. A revised enforcement regulation alongside it would let the Commission investigate big cross-border cases itself.
Most coverage reads it as a list: dark patterns, loot boxes, subscription traps, influencers. Read it as a marketer and one idea runs through the whole thing. Every persuasive claim in your funnel would need something true behind it, and someone would be allowed to ask to see it.
What actually lands on the blacklist
The heart of the proposal is Annex I, the list of practices that are unfair in all circumstances. No balancing test. If you do it, it is unfair. According to TLT’s analysis, the list grows from 47 items to 62, and I counted the same 62 in the annex text. Several of the new ones read like a Black Friday creative brief.
The reference price rule is the one that will hurt. New point 11 bans a price comparison that shows a percentage saving, a money saving or a crossed-out reference price, unless the reference is “a current price charged for the product by a clearly identified competitor on the market.” The recital spells out what that means: comparisons against “mere estimated or recommended prices, such as the manufacturer’s recommended retail price” are out. Second-hand or refurbished goods can still be compared with the new price. Wilson Sonsini and Beyond the Basket read it the same way: an RRP stops being a usable “was” price.
Your own markdowns are a different animal. The recital says the comparison rules are without prejudice to the Price Indication Directive, which since May 28, 2022 has required any announced price reduction to show the lowest price you charged in the previous 30 days. So “was €199, now €149” against your own real 30-day low stays possible. “RRP €249, now €149, save 40%” is the thing on the list.

Drip pricing goes too. New point 12 requires the first price shown to include every foreseeable fee the shopper cannot avoid. The recital names a fixed delivery fee as an example and carves out delivery costs that genuinely depend on the address or the basket size.
Then the urgency stack. New point 14 bans saying an offer is available for a very limited time without disclosing how long it lasts. The new dark patterns section adds ten more, and two of them are aimed squarely at conversion rate teams. Point 53 bans false claims about availability or popularity, or failing to clearly disclose the qualifications behind them. Point 54 bans “persistently displaying statements throughout the ordering process about the availability or popularity of a product or promotional offer to create an impression of scarcity.” That second one does not require the claim to be false. A true “only 3 left” that chases the shopper through every checkout step is the practice.
The rest of the ten will look familiar to anyone who has sat through a growth review: pre-ticked paid add-ons, making the decline button the “wrong” choice, nagging people to change a choice they already made, fake notifications, and making it far harder to say no than to say yes.
The creator post and the gift box
Article 11 handles influencer marketing, and the wording is specific enough to change a brief. Disclosure has to be made “for each commercial communication, through the terms ‘advertisement’ or ‘commercial collaboration’,” and on platforms covered by the Digital Services Act it has to use the platform’s own disclosure feature. The recital adds that it should appear at the outset and stay visible for the whole piece. A hashtag buried after twelve others is not what anyone drafting this had in mind.
The part brands should read twice is paragraph 6. Any trader using influencer marketing “shall ensure contractually, or in the absence of a contract through other appropriate means,” that the creator complies. The recital says brands and agencies are liable “irrespective of the type of payment granted to the influencer,” including gifts and invitations, and “irrespective of the degree of editorial freedom.” It also says a contract cannot be used to push the brand’s own liability onto the creator. Where there is no contract, as with gifts sent solicited or unsolicited, the brand still has to take effective measures.
That kills the most comfortable sentence in seeding programs: “we just send product, what they post is up to them.” Under this text, the box is the payment and the brand owns the label.
Article 36 gives a trader held liable a right of recourse against a commercial partner whose act or omission caused or contributed to the breach. Read plainly, a brand fined over an agency-run creator campaign could go after the agency. Expect that to show up in master service agreements long before it shows up in court.
Paid picks in shopping agents need a yes
Article 26 covers software that concludes contracts on a consumer’s behalf, which is a lawyer’s way of saying shopping agents. It gets the least marketing attention and may shape media buying the most.
On first use, the consumer has to choose: confirm every purchase, confirm only some (with criteria such as a maximum price), or confirm nothing. The agent provider has to honor that choice. But under Article 26(4)(b), the agent must disclose “any payment received” for proposing a contract and any conflict of interest with the seller, and in that case it must “require the consumer to confirm the corresponding contract, independently of the choice expressed by the consumer.”
If you pay to be the pick inside a shopping assistant, the shopper who chose full autonomy still gets a confirmation step for your product, and probably not for the unpaid alternative. Sponsored placement in agents does not disappear. It just loses the one thing that made it sound magical, the purchase that happens without a human looking. Bristows flags the open questions: whether a commission paid only after a sale counts as payment “for proposing” a contract, and whether a retailer’s own agent recommending its own stock is conflicted. Neither is settled.
Targeting and the evidence clause
Two more articles change the back office.
Article 12 takes the Digital Services Act’s ban on profiling-based ads using special categories of personal data, or aimed at people the trader knows with reasonable certainty are minors, and extends it from big platforms to every trader. The platforms already covered by the DSA are carved out because they already live under it. Everyone else, meaning advertisers, retailers running their own media networks and the ad tech in between, would inherit the rule. If your CRM has a segment that is really a health condition wearing a lifestyle label, that segment becomes a problem anywhere you use it to target ads.
Article 34 is the one I would pin above the conversion team’s desk. It lets courts and authorities, once a claimant shows a likely unfair practice online or an authority has reasonable suspicion, require the trader to disclose “relevant evidence in relation to the design, operation and impact on the behaviour of consumers” of the practice. Failing to hand it over can count against you. Your A/B test archive is exactly that evidence. A test deck showing that a persistent scarcity banner lifted checkout completion by eleven points would be, in this world, a document proving the banner distorted behavior.
The money is serious. National authorities would need fines of at least 4% of a trader’s turnover in the member states concerned, and the Commission could fine up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover for widespread cross-border infringements it investigates itself, according to Article 35 and Mason Hayes Curran’s summary.
Why bother this week, for a law years away
This is a proposal. The European Parliament and the Council still have to agree on it, and the text says it would apply 12 months after it enters into force. Wilson Sonsini expects negotiations to run at least until the end of 2027 and likely into 2028. The wording will change. Industry groups and consumer groups have both already pushed back.
Nobody needs to rebuild a checkout before Thanksgiving. Three things still make this Black Friday the moment to act.
First, this sale is the largest single sample of your promotional mechanics you will collect all year. Every reference price, urgency banner, fee display and creator post is live at once. Documenting it now costs a screenshot. Reconstructing it in 2028 costs a project.
Second, the contracts you write in the next eight weeks will still be running when this lands. Creator retainers, agency renewals and early deals for sponsored placement in AI shopping assistants are all being drafted for 2027. Clauses are cheap to add at signing and expensive to renegotiate.
Third, it is not only Brussels. In the UK, drip pricing and fake reviews have already been banned under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act since April 2025, as Beyond the Basket notes, and the proposal lets the Commission add dark patterns to the blacklist later by delegated act. The direction of travel is not in doubt, only the date.

What to do before the sale
Run a reference price census. Pull every strike-through and percentage badge you plan to show in the EU and tag its source: your own 30-day low, a named competitor’s current price, or an RRP. Count the RRP ones. That number is your exposure.
Find out what the RRP badge is actually worth. Pick one EU market and one category and run the sale with your own 30-day low or a plain price instead of the RRP comparison. If conversion barely moves, you have learned the badge was decoration. If it collapses, you have learned how much of your Black Friday is built on a claim with an expiry date, and finance should hear that now.
Wire every scarcity claim to real stock. For each “only X left” and “selling fast,” write down where the number comes from. If nobody can answer, turn it off. Then remove repeat scarcity messages from the checkout steps even where they are true, and put an end date on every countdown.
Put fixed fees in the first price. Any delivery or service fee that does not depend on the address or basket belongs in the headline price for EU and UK shoppers.
Rewrite the seeding note. Every holiday gift box going to a creator should carry a short written request to label the post with the platform’s disclosure feature and the word “advertisement” or “commercial collaboration.” Paid briefs should say the same thing in the contract, and agencies should expect brands to ask for recourse language in renewals.
Ask your agent vendors one question in writing. Anyone selling you sponsored placement in a shopping assistant should tell you how paid recommendations will be disclosed and whether they will need shopper confirmation. Do not price 2027 agent deals on the assumption of zero-click checkout.
Write test logs as if someone will read them. Not to hide anything, which Article 34 would punish, but so the record shows what each urgency or pricing test was based on and why it ran. Then flag any audience segment built on inferred health or other sensitive traits that feeds ad targeting outside the big platforms.
Black Friday has always run on a little theatre: the “was” price nobody paid, the clock that resets tomorrow, the stock count that never quite reaches zero. Brussels has not banned selling. It has drafted a rule that the claims behind the selling have to be true and on file. The brands that start keeping receipts this month will spend 2028 changing settings. Everyone else will spend it in a war room.




